Killing with the Cure:
World Bank's Role in Africa Pesticides Cleanup Raises New Threats
by Anabela Lemos and Nityanand Jayaraman
American International School of Mozambique/Livaningo and independent journalist, India
More than 50,000 tons of poisonous pesticides lie virtually
abandoned in various countries around Africa. Strewn around,
unrecorded, stored in leaking containers near schoolyards, residential
areas and farmland, these poisons represent a deadly legacy
left behind in Africa by multinational chemical companies, often
working in tandem with "development" agencies like
the World Bank.
An initiative called the Africa Stockpiles Project (ASP) is
working to remove and destroy these pesticides. But the World
Bank's involvement in the project raises a new concern related
to how the pesticides will be disposed. The concern arises from
the Bank's continued support of dangerously polluting "disposal"
methods like incinerators and cement kilns. For the Africa Stockpiles
Project, the World Bank is the designated "lead agency.
African and international public interest groups say that there
is a need to ensure that the Bank doesn't push for the burning
of these wastes in incinerators or cement kilns. Incinerators
and cement kilns contribute substantially to global pollution
by producing deadly poisons such as dioxins and furans. According
to a 2001 survey by Essential Action, at least 79 World Bank
projects in 47 countries have involved incineration in recent
years.
"It would indeed be ironic if the World Bank left Africa
saddled with a new legacy of polluting incinerators and cement
kilns set up to destroy an earlier legacy caused by pesticides
dumped on Africa by aid and trade organizations," said
Mauricio Sulila of Mozambique-based community group Livaningo.
Dioxins and furans, the by-products of incinerators and cement
kilns, are among the most toxic substances known to science.
Some of them are known carcinogens, and are implicated in sabotaging
body processes by interfering with vital systems such as the
immune, hormonal and reproductive systems.
In 1999, Livaningo, supported by public interest groups from
around the world, defeated a proposal by the Danish Government
to burn Mozambique's pesticide stockpiles in a local cement
kiln retrofitted with Danish technology. The Danish government
recently announced that it will end the practice of burning
hazardous wastes in cement kilns.
Pesticides stockpiles, including those found in Mozambique,
are in large part a result of programs packaged as aid. Between
1988 and 1995, the World Bank financed the purchase of $250.75
million worth of pesticides, mostly from Western pesticide multinationals,
on behalf of Southern nations, according to Pesticide Action
Network North America's briefing paper titled "Poison Profits
- The G7 Pesticide Industry's Stake in the World Bank."
For several years now, the Pesticide Action Network UK (PAN
UK), part a global network of public-interest groups advocating
reduced reliance on chemical pesticides, together with the UN's
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) has sought to bring
world attention to the problem of rotting pesticide stockpiles
in Africa and other places in the industrializing world. Their
efforts received a considerable boost with the recently signed
Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs)
in May 2001.
POPs are a category of life-threatening human-made chemicals
which do not degrade in the environment and are linked to a
variety of debilitating health conditions including cancers,
immune system disorders and serious reproductive anomalies such
as infertility, endometriosis and falling sperm counts. The
Stockholm Convention currently targets 12 POP chemicals
nine of them pesticides such as DDT and Aldrin, and three toxic
chemicals such as dioxins, furans and polychlorinated biphenyls
(PCBs) which occur in emissions from incinerators, waste
burners and other industries involving chlorine-based processes.
As part of the Convention's requirements to move towards a
world without POPs, the international treaty mandates the identification,
containment and eventual destruction of stockpiles of obsolete
pesticides. Such stockpiles are currently spread out all over
the industrializing world. It also calls upon rich countries
to financially assist poorer nations to address their POPs problems.
Many of the toxic pesticides stockpiled in Africa are POPs.
PAN-UK and World Wildlife Fund (WWF) floated the idea of the
Africa Stockpiles Project, a comprehensive, continent-wide effort
to contain, remove and destroy all of Africa's obsolete pesticides.
In the eight months since the idea was first mooted in December
2001 in Johannesburg, South Africa, it has garnered support
from a wide range of NGOs and intergovernmental organizations,
including the FAO and the World Bank. The scope of the project,
a ten-year effort costing upwards of $200 million, is commensurate
with the magnitude of the problem.
The FAO is currently conducting an inventory of the stockpiles
of pesticides accumulated in various Southern countries. So
far, 25,000 tons of obsolete pesticides have been identified
in Africa alone. Experience suggests that the actual size of
the stockpiles will grow to several times this amount, after
comprehensive estimates, including the quantum of contaminated
soil and equipment, become available.
PAN-UK acknowledges that incineration has been the primary
method of treating obsolete pesticides, but notes that the Africa
Stockpiles Project offers the possibility of treating obsolete
pesticides without the generation of deadly chemicals like dioxins
and furans. Several recently introduced non-combustion technologies
hold the potential of destroying chlorinated wastes without
the generation of POPs emissions. In fact, some of these technologies
may be tried out to destroy PCB wastes in the Philip-
|