Energizing a Worldwide Movement
by Tony Avirgan
Development GAP
50 Years Is Enough has joined with 1000 civil society organizations
worldwide to support the launching of the Structural Adjustment
Participatory Review Initiative (SAPRI), an initiative of citizens'
organizations in conjunction with the World Bank and governments
to assess through gender inclusive, participatory processes
the impact of structural adjustment programs (SAPs). Officially
launched in Washington on 14 July 1997, the purpose of SAPRI is
to identify and set the stage for appropriate changes in adjustment
operations and programs and for more participatory and effective
economic-policymaking processes.
SAPRI was born in the early days of the Wolfensohn presidency out
of a meeting with a group of U.S. and international NGOs led by
the Washington-based Development GAP. At that meeting, NGOs proposed
that the Bank undertake a bottom-up review of adjustment programs
in conjunction with local organizations. Wolfensohn accepted the
challenge and NGO leaders and Bank officials began to work out the
details of the exercise. Two years later, significant progress has
been made, though many details are still being worked out.
To date, eight countries are part of the official SAPRI process
(Ghana, Mali, Uganda, Zimbabwe, Hungary, Ecuador, El Salvador and
Bangladesh). The program is directed by an international steering
committee with 2/3rds Southern country representation. Each national
investigation will commence with a public forum where adjustment-related
issues will be discussed and problem areas identified. These will
be investigated by a civil-society/Bank team through field work
that will rely primarily on participatory and gender-inclusive techniques
designed to take into account qualitative, as well as quantitative,
information. The field findings will be presented, discussed and
assessed at a follow-up forum in each country and concrete actions
related to changes in national adjustment programs, the opening
of the adjustment-planning process to broad local participation,
and modifications in the Bank's own adjustment-planning instruments
will be determined. These findings and agreed-upon actions from
each of the country exercises will then be presented at a major
forum in Washington.
The process has not been without problems. For example, the SAPRI
civil-society Network Steering Committee has expressed its displeasure
to the World Bank over the fact that the institution has been unsuccessful
in engaging large emerging-market economies (such as Mexico and
the Philippines, where there is also strong civil-society interest
in SAPRI) in the Initiative, despite the fact that they have received
billions of dollars in adjustment-related lending from the Bank
and are used as models for other countries to follow. Even more
disturbing is that the Bank has refused to even solicit government
cooperation in other countries, including Argentina, which, like
Mexico, have implemented an economic program that has had a disastrous
impact on most of its population. In each of the aforementioned
"excluded" countries, citizens' organizations are considering
moving ahead with a SAPRI-like exercise, extending an invitation
to the government and the World Bank to join the process. The SAPRI
Network (SAPRIN) is supporting these initiatives, as well.
Despite the new openings for dialogue that SAPRI as well
as the ever-broadening public challenges to SAPs has created,
the civil-society organizations involved in SAPRI are not naive
about the possibilities of the exercise resulting in a change in
the World Bank's fundamental economic policies. In fact, it is not
lost on anyone that, while the Bank uses SAPRI to demonstrate that
it is doing something on the adjustment issue with its critics and
civil society generally, it is considering TIGHTENING the adjustment
noose around the necks of borrower governments. If SAPRI does achieve
its goal of creating greater flexibility for governments to respond
to the knowledge and priorities of their own people and significant
change in the reform agenda does emerge from the exercise
it will be an important victory. But, as SAPRI progresses, participating
groups are seeing that its greatest value may prove to be the breaking
down of barriers that have traditionally divided civil society and
the building, on the national and international level, of large,
powerful coalitions demanding popular participation in the making
of just economic policies.
For more information visit the SAPRIN web site:
www.igc.org/dgap/saprin
The Development GAP
927 15th Street, NW
Washington, DC 20005
Tel: 202/898-1566
|