Tax the World Bank
by Njoki Njoroge Njehu
50 Years Is Enough Network
Washington, DC is notorious for pothole-ridden streets,
pockets of deep poverty with few reliable services, and, at the
root of it all, a city government mired in financial and political
bankruptcy. Amidst this virtual decay, within six blocks of the
White House, sit some 25 buildings occupied wholly or in part
by the World Bank and its nearly ten thousand Washington-based
employees.
The World Bank, which calls itself a development
institution with a primary mandate to alleviate poverty, pays
no taxes to the District of Columbia. That means no property tax
payments for the prime real estate it occupies, and no sales tax
revenues for the district. Its employees are even exempt from
federal and local income taxes! By providing standard municipal
services and a unique location, the impoverished city of Washington
subsidizes an institution which made a profit of $1.3 billion
in 1996. Much of that profit, of course, comes from loan repayments
from governments that have, under World Bank structural adjustment
programs, had to eliminate subsidies for all sorts of desperately
poor citizens.
Like the United Nations, the World Bank is classified
as an international treaty organization, exempt from all U.S.
taxes, (including sales tax). Unlike the U.N., it turns a huge
profit. Last Tax Day (April 15, 1997), a coalition led by 50 Years
is Enough's Domestic Links Caucus demonstrated outside the World
Bank's spanking-new gold-trimmed $314 million headquarters building.
We laid out these facts as part of our call to "Say No to
International Corporate Welfare." Now the coalition that
formed for that event is preparing a campaign to get the Bank
to pay what it owes the city. We will be laying the groundwork
for the campaign in the next couple months, and "go public"
on April 15, 1998.
We will propose to World Bank President James Wolfensohn
that his institution agree to make Payments in Lieu of Taxes (PILOTS)
voluntary payments provided by some large tax-exempt institutions
in recognition of the value of the services and location afforded
by their host city. Those payments should approximate the revenues
the city would get if the World Bank paid property and sales taxes
at the rate a normal bank does, and if their employees paid income
taxes like the rest of us do. Institutions such as the National
Education Association in Washington, the Port Authority in New
York City, and Yale University (on a small portion of its buildings)
in New Haven, Connecticut all make PILOTS.
Its official status as an international treaty organization,
notwithstanding, the World Bank is more like a normal bank than
a development institution. With its $1.3 billion profit (which
they call net income), the Bank is not your typical non-profit
institution! As an advertisement it placed in the New York Times
in May 1995 puts it, "The World Bank is just what it says
it is a bank that invests in the world. [...] The World
Bank works because it runs like a bank." But Washington DC
doesn't work, in part, because the World Bank and similar institutions
located there do not pay taxes like other banks do.
If Mr. Wolfensohn and the World Bank Board agree
to pay PILOTS, we will pressure the Bank's sister institutions,
the International Monetary Fund and the Inter-American Development
Bank, both located in Washington as well, to do likewise. If they
do not agree to our proposal, we will take the campaign to the
next step: a drive to change the institutions' tax-exempt status
so that they would be required to pay the taxes Washington so
desperately needs. Come April 15, we will be asking 50 Years is
Enough members around the U.S. to get in touch with their representatives
to support this campaign for basic justice for the city and people
of Washington, D.C.
A coalition of national and Washington, DC-based
organizations have been working on this campaign. They include
last year's Tax Day event sponsors, the Bay Area 50 Years is Enough
Coalition, Bosnia Support Committee, D.C. Committee in Solidarity
with the People of El Salvador (CISPES), D.C. East Timor Action
Network (ETAN), Friends of the Earth (FoE), National Child Rights
Alliance, Peace Action, Pledge of Resistance (DC), Project South
(Washington Area), D.C. Statehood Party, The Washington Peace
Center, and Women's International League for Peace and Freedom
(WILPF), along with some new DC-issue based organizations that
we are cultivating.
|